GMU 17 Elk (Help!)

hunter101 · Wednesday at 10:46 AM

Good Day All!

I have the 1st archery elk tag coming up in just a few weeks and am asking for pointers fellas. I have hunted elk many times, no issues there. I am familiar with the southern part of this unit but I've mainly hunted for deer in 17. Been out there these past few weeks but not having any luck locating elk on the southern end of the unit near Monticello/Vicks Peak Area. With folks that are experienced with this unit would you say that I should focus more towards the north side of the unit near Magdalena or is it safe to say that I should continue to focus on the southern part of the unit? I am driving out of Doña Ana, NM so its not to far of a drive, but not as familiar with the northern part of this unit. I've been out towards Monica Cabin and checked the area, but not sure if thats a good area to focus for archery, any help is greatly appreciated!

Mike0426 · Wednesday at 1:28 PM

PM sent

muleybeast · Wednesday at 8:50 PM

We used to draw itbevertbyear

Haven’t drawn it in about ten years now.

That cabin is at the farthest northern end of the unit

We usually hunt way further south

Lots of private and outfitters up by where you are at

Lots of elk move east into 17 from 16

There are some nasty hell holes in 17 and that’s whether hey will be

We have killed lots of 330+ bulls on west slopes of San Mateo mountains

Pine Tank and Kelly Canyon are our favorite spots

ortegageno · Thursday at 2:19 PM

Used to be your favorite spots!

smarba · Thursday at 6:34 PM

Yeah no kidding, "used to be"

hunter101 · Friday at 12:12 PM

I really appreciate all the positive comments! Not trying to take anyone's spot. Just asking for some pointers in that area. I hunt 36/34 all the time and can exchange information for those units as well. Any help is greatly appreciated! Plenty of Land to hunt for us all, its not like I'm going to magically land an elk lol got to put in the work, put boots on the ground, locate wildlife and create a plan of action. Here is a pic I got from going into 17 this past weekend, there is a lot of land to cover.

muleybeast · Friday at 6:28 PM

Yeah you know I’m sick of you little bitchez complaining when a guy gives someone a little help. You sound like a bunch of democrat libtards censoring our posts. If you don’t like us sharing hunting spots and information about hunting then leave this forum. After all it’s a forum created by an amazing hunter to share information with other hunters. Imagine that.

Jeez what a couple of tools. The hunting Gods. The hunting overlords. STFU!!!!

billc · Saturday at 5:20 AM

I know when I came on this site over 12 years ago the help I got was amazing. I then stayed extra days to learn all I could.and if we were lucky and finished are hunt early I kept scouting. I help anyone I can and shared the info I knew about 17 and I think that is just doing my part for all the help I got

DBR · Saturday at 8:37 AM

I’ve got a 17 tag too. Don’t complain if I beat you to these spots we will be hunting hard and aggressive. There will be 5 of us together, one tag, never been in the unit we will take all the help we can get. Live 1800 miles from the unit so we can’t scout. What’s the best cameo for 17 ? Should we hit Pine Tank first or is it better to hit Kelly Canyon first ? We are willing to pay some locals for inside info when we get there. Should we hold out for a 350 plus the first week ?

Reuben_Soady · Sunday at 10:49 PM

I definately recommend holding out for 350" or better.

Oh and by posting details in the forum like @muleybeast did instead of using PM (like @billc probably did) you're not "giving a guy a little help." You may actually be ruining the hunt for him by spilling beans to every internet scouter and his team that searches for "GMU ##" over the next ... how many years?

muleybeast · 2024-08-19T07:13:02-0600

Dang man I’m so sorry Reuben. I didn’t mean to give away the last hiding spot in unit 17 of the last 350 Bull. Man what a bad person I am. Shuck E Darn. I feel terrible now. May the public forum Gods continue to shame me.

Reuben_Soady · 2024-08-19T08:09:37-0600

muleybeast said:
We used to draw itbevertbyear
Haven’t drawn it in about ten years now.

Assuming that you're still applying for this unit, have you ever wonder why you can't draw it anymore?

Mallardsx2 · 2024-08-19T08:46:13-0600

There's no putting this genie back in the bottle....

You might as well help the guy who is lucky enough to be hunting it now.

priley · 2024-08-19T20:56:28-0600

Shuck E Darn....lmao

DBR · 2024-08-19T22:29:10-0600

Just picked up another buddy that is going to make the trip with us. New plan is to sit two guys at different spots and txt info back and forth as we acquire it. We are bringing 3 SXS with us to get to destinations fast. Think I’ll send a team up near Monica Cabin to recon then txt back info and long/lat. If the sightings are few we may break off into one man teams to cover more ground. Great info so far ! Keep it coming. If I can find two more buddies to help I might set them up on the San Meteo Mts and sweep down to cover ground another team couldn’t get to for a day or two. Also plan on filming so not looking for dinks, looking to know where big bulls will be or have been taken.

muleybeast · 2024-08-20T07:23:48-0600

May a large phallus shaped object penetrate you from behind.

For you not educated enough to comprende go F… yourselves.

If I want to share hunting information I can. DBR your little tongue in cheek game grows old. We used to be able to communicate openly and share hunting info. Now all you internet all stars think all the game animals are reserved to you and your homies. I bet every one of you at some time got info from a dad a grandpa an uncle a friend about some specific unit or area. How is that different.

I’m really starting to think that I want to blast all my hotspots on here. This will really piss some of you off. I can see it now. Monster Muleys forum member road rage incident. GTFO

hunter101 · 2024-08-20T08:29:57-0600

Again just want to say for those that have helped and posted positive feedback thank you! I really do appreciate you. Those who just think that all these spots will automatically be taken or that it will automatically draw other hunters... sure... but first they have to know how to hunt 2nd good luck on the draw! At the end of the day, hunting is hunting. Some people road hunt, some hunt aggressively and on foot, I hunt because I love to hunt! I don't care about no trophy bull, I lays mine to eat. At the end of the day Every man knows their skills and I sure know how to use mine. Do I need some help?? sure, I think at one point we all needed some guidance, but once your in the field... then its time to go to work. You can hunt these canyons all you want

cause at the end of the day I know the type of hunter that I am, If I do harvest that will be the icing on the cake, To me its about being there with My Fam! Enjoying every precious time! Hope those that drew this unit are successful regardless of how you feel, See you out in the field...