New world record?

hornkiller · Wednesday at 5:10 PM

Claiming it scores 238"?

BradA · Wednesday at 5:13 PM

What state ?

AZGuy · Wednesday at 5:15 PM

BradA said:
What state ?

CO

DeerAddiction4 · Wednesday at 5:20 PM

I can’t see 238. I saw massntrash say 230+
The extras aren’t enough I don’t think.

tailchasers · Wednesday at 5:21 PM

Looks like a flat land muley. Or at least along a flatter river bottom.

MountainSqwabler · Wednesday at 5:23 PM

"Hold on a second let me take a solo Pic with your buck"!!!....wtf Is the second guy doing haha.

smokepolejohnson · Wednesday at 5:28 PM

Congrats on an Amazing Buck. It definitely has a backyard/ HOA feel..
Regardless congrats to all involved

hornkiller · Wednesday at 5:37 PM

No info just rumors I've heard 225-238 people trying to get like on insta this buck has been dead for a couple days!

deerslayer64d · Wednesday at 5:42 PM

No words just WOW

BrianID · Wednesday at 5:48 PM

Absolutely giant main frame 4 point. I wouldn’t doubt a rough gross green score of 238”. After deductions and stripping the velvet, I really doubt it is bigger than the Burris Buck. I wouldn’t be surprised if net was higher than P&Y Gardner Buck.

I don’t see any tags in the ears. Something so big, makes me suspicious of high fences. Hope it is a legit free range buck.

2lumpy · Wednesday at 7:30 PM

You been holding out on us blue. Those pictures look like Colorado River bottom cottonwoods, from your neck of the woods.

DeerHunter53 · Thursday at 10:03 AM

It does look like Colorado river bottoms like the ones around Grand Junction. If this buck it for real it's amazing that he has survived as long as he did......

twdjr · Thursday at 10:15 AM

Homer · Thursday at 11:38 AM

DeerAddiction4 said:
I can’t see 238. I saw massntrash say 230+
The extras aren’t enough I don’t think.

The extras are too much….I think….

Ckleeves · Thursday at 11:39 AM

MountainSqwabler said:
"Hold on a second let me take a solo Pic with your buck"!!!....wtf Is the second guy doing haha.

The second pic down is the guy who killed it. It’s 100% a free range buck.

1989Cohunter · Thursday at 12:01 PM

Fake news

nfh · Thursday at 12:07 PM

Glad to see other people hunt in blue jeans to.

dont need that overpriced kuiu or sitka

MountainSqwabler · Thursday at 12:16 PM

Ckleeves said:
The second pic down is the guy who killed it. It’s 100% a free range buck.

Ok so why did the first guy take a pic with it then?? Just wanting to look cool without someone else's trophy?

elkhunterUT · Thursday at 12:19 PM

MountainSqwabler said:
Ok so why did the first guy take a pic with it then?? Just wanting to look cool without someone else's trophy?

guessing it was the guide/outfitter - gotta have those pics for the Gram, ya know?!?!

MountainSqwabler · Thursday at 12:20 PM

elkhunterUT said:
guessing it was the guide/outfitter - gotta have those pics for the Gram, ya know?!?!

I mean....I guess haha. My guide didn't want any pictures with my bull. Wasn't a legendary buck like that but still.

2lumpy · Thursday at 12:22 PM

elkhunterUT said:
guessing it was the guide/outfitter - gotta have those pics for the Gram, ya know?!?!

LOL…….hell, if I drove by that thing, we’d walk over and get a selfie with it myself.

elkhunterUT · Thursday at 12:23 PM

2lumpy said:
LOL…….hell, if I drove by that thing, we’d walk over and get a selfie with it myself.

and I wouldn't hate you for that

That buck is certainly impressive!!!!

ORIONTHEHUNTER · Thursday at 12:29 PM

Is that Cory mcilveen the bonehead antler buyer holding it?

Tikka · Thursday at 12:29 PM

I think they bludgeoned that buck to death...

How does a capped buck get that blood shot...

What a fantastic buck and congrats to the hunter...

wapitiman · Thursday at 1:20 PM

Big fella

ktg · Thursday at 1:25 PM

MountainSqwabler said:
Ok so why did the first guy take a pic with it then?? Just wanting to look cool without someone else's trophy?

You ever seen Doyle Moss pose with an animal he didn't kill? lol

Triple7 · Thursday at 1:56 PM

Hopefully he bred a lot of does last fall and passed them genetics on. Exceptional buck !

yoteduster · Thursday at 2:15 PM

Really nice buck... But after the stripping and drying period and deductions I don't think he knocks the Burris buck off the podium.. But anyway congrats to the hunter

The_Coloradoboy · Thursday at 2:28 PM

ORIONTHEHUNTER said:
Is that Cory mcilveen the bonehead antler buyer holding it?

Yes

Homer · Thursday at 2:35 PM

Well……he’s amost certainly P&Y territory….

Slick8 · Thursday at 2:51 PM

No idea on the score but I wouldn't pass it with a broken beam...

It would gross 350 if they'd hold it a little farther back.

Homer · Thursday at 5:55 PM

WR P&Y is 205 6/8........very well might be new WR

Velvet WR is 218 2/8......maybe

elkassassin · Thursday at 7:10 PM

There's A Measurer In KALI That Could Probably Drop It Down From 238" A Bit & PISS Somebody Off In The Process!

JPickett · Thursday at 7:13 PM

What’s the point of long arming a 238” buck? Douche bags…

hossblur · Thursday at 7:26 PM

Given the last 12 months how many guys , like me, have waited to comment, just waiting for the "other" shoe to drop? I've waited 3 days so I guess it's safe?

That's a beautiful deer. Congrats to everyone involved.

And yup, any deer or elk I help pack, I get a pic with, thems the rules

elkassassin · Thursday at 8:17 PM

I'd Guess Since You're 6' 13" Tall You Got Some Perty Long Arms Hossy?

How Wide You Figure You Could Make That Buck Look With Your Arm Length & A Fish Eye?

hossblur said:
Given the last 12 months how many guys , like me, have waited to comment, just waiting for the "other" shoe to drop? I've waited 3 days so I guess it's safe?

That's a beautiful deer. Congrats to everyone involved.

And yup, any deer or elk I help pack, I get a pic with, thems the rules

Tristate · Friday at 6:51 AM

Hellavu deer.

Hellavu fancy pic

Tikka · Friday at 8:14 AM

Now that I’ve had time to process this buck and timing of his demise…

I’m betting this is the 230” that Zim has been seeing on the Paunsagunt… The minions figured out his location from the pics he’s been posting…
Damn minions, can’t trust them anymore…

Togwotee · Friday at 8:39 AM

Great buck, but no way to judge it off those pictures. when a guy's hand is bigger than his head you know it's a good picture.

osu92 · Friday at 10:46 AM

JPickett said:
What’s the point of long arming a 238” buck? Douche bags…

Guys just looking for something to be pissed about when others find success. Always fun to read. The two pics in the field the guys are literally sitting as tight to the body and head as they can get. The caped photo, sure he's holding it out, but what's he supposed to do? Hold it against his chest?

Vanilla · Friday at 1:06 PM

What a specimen! Just a truly awesome mule deer.

And I’d 100% be taking a pic with that buck if I was there no matter who killed it.

Vanilla · Friday at 2:03 PM

nfh said:
Glad to see other people hunt in blue jeans to.

dont need that overpriced kuiu or sitka

This made me laugh since the guy is wearing a Sitka shirt and Sitka bino case in the same pic.

JPickett · Friday at 3:05 PM

osu92 said:
Guys just looking for something to be pissed about when others find success. Always fun to read. The two pics in the field the guys are literally sitting as tight to the body and head as they can get. The caped photo, sure he's holding it out, but what's he supposed to do? Hold it against his chest?

You really believe that bucks head is bigger then the hunters entire torso? Ok. It’s a huge buck, like said a couple post up, you can’t tell how huge because the pics are so ridiculous. It would be way more impressive not long armed. Maybe that’s a 180 buck by those pics? Who could tell

Homer · Friday at 4:03 PM

I just don't see the problem with the pics.....

2lumpy · Friday at 4:14 PM

Homer said:
I just don't see the problem with the pics.....

What…….. it’s plan to see… his ears shrink and his antlers grow, when you push his nose into the camera lens.

Tikka · Friday at 4:51 PM

Folks need to get over themselves when it comes to scrutinizing pictures…

That’s a fantastic buck anyone of you’d shoot in a New York minute…

nfh · Friday at 5:41 PM

Vanilla said:
This made me laugh since the guy is wearing a Sitka shirt and Sitka bino case in the same pic.

I didn't notice that. Lol

txhunter58 · Friday at 5:52 PM

Fantastic amazing buck. Not a world record. But who cares.

Vanilla · Friday at 5:56 PM

Tikka said:
Folks need to get over themselves when it comes to scrutinizing pictures…

That’s a fantastic buck anyone of you’d shoot in a New York minute…

I’ve seen this for a long time in the fishing world.

They’ll get over it, or they won’t. Take whatever pics you want! If someone doesn’t like it, they don’t have to look.

Homer · Friday at 9:17 PM

txhunter58 said:
Fantastic amazing buck. Not a world record. But who cares.

P&Y?......

elkassassin · 2024-09-07T04:56:01-0600

Well Tikka!

I Don't Disagree With You Very Often!

But I'm Disagreeing With You On This One!

I Wouldn't Shoot That Buck In A New York Minute!

But I Would In A New York Second!

Tikka said:
Folks need to get over themselves when it comes to scrutinizing pictures…

That’s a fantastic buck anyone of you’d shoot in a New York minute…

elkassassin · 2024-09-07T05:04:01-0600

Nothing To Do With The Buck In This Thread!

A Few Years Back There Was A Buck Posted Here On MM!

Perty Damn Impressing Buck Pic!

I Wondered About a Possible Fish-Eye?

Then I Seen The Buck On The Wall A Couple Years Later!

He Definitely Lost A Bunch Of Inches The Time He Hit The Wall!

elkassassin · 2024-09-07T05:21:28-0600

Hey Hossy?

How Bout When You Can Drive Your YOTA Right To The Kill Site/Buck To Help A Guy Out?

Would That Require A Picture As Well?

hossblur said:
Given the last 12 months how many guys , like me, have waited to comment, just waiting for the "other" shoe to drop? I've waited 3 days so I guess it's safe?

That's a beautiful deer. Congrats to everyone involved.

And yup, any deer or elk I help pack, I get a pic with, thems the rules

Buckfever34 · 2024-09-07T06:31:18-0600

muleyczy · 2024-09-07T06:44:01-0600

Whatever it scores, it’s a buck of a lifetime imo. Congratulations!

Tikka · 2024-09-07T07:28:19-0600

elkassassin said:
Well Tikka!

I Don't Disagree With You Very Often!

But I'm Disagreeing With You On This One!

I Wouldn't Shoot That Buck In A New York Minute!

But I Would In A New York Second!

I don’t disagree with myself very often either…

I’m not as fast as I used too be, so it might take me a New York second and a half..,

Castnshoot · 2024-09-07T07:44:53-0600

Let’s say the photo is not taken with a fish eye lens,,, what is your guess on the old school way of judging a Muley. Width?

35 to 36 inches

elkhunterUT · 2024-09-07T08:24:37-0600

elkassassin said:
Nothing To Do With The Buck In This Thread!

A Few Years Back There Was A Buck Posted Here On MM!

Perty Damn Impressing Buck Pic!

I Wondered About a Possible Fish-Eye?

Then I Seen The Buck On The Wall A Couple Years Later!

He Definitely Lost A Bunch Of Inches The Time He Hit The Wall!

I think you’re confused -you have to be talking about StinkyStompers 380” Dutton bull that was really 320” in real life. The photoshopped pic with broken antler added in didn’t help either

Butts · 2024-09-07T20:32:34-0600

226 net

Butts · 2024-09-07T20:35:02-0600

Easily P&Y velvet WR.

Tikka · 2024-09-07T20:40:27-0600

elkhunterUT said:
I think you’re confused -you have to be talking about StinkyStompers 380” Dutton bull that was really 320” in real life. The photoshopped pic with broken antler added in didn’t help either

I think they have an app for that… it’s called add inches… There’s a couple of guys we went to school with that used that app 3 years ago on a Colorado mule deer hunt…