Guess The Score #3

DeerAddiction4 · Oct 3, 2024

We killed this buck in 2022. What do think he scores? I’ll post the score on Tuesday.

DeerAddiction4 · Oct 3, 2024

I’ll have to find some more pictures later.

JakeH · Oct 3, 2024

I got 199, long beams on that guy. 190ish frame with 8-9 inches of extras.

Gunnihunter · Oct 3, 2024

muzz · Oct 3, 2024

208”

Joe2Kool · Oct 3, 2024

196-1/8
I was 40" low on Buck #2. But I don't think this one is as big as he was.

CC11 · Oct 3, 2024

198 3/8

fullthrottle · Oct 4, 2024

Buckfever34 · Oct 4, 2024

yoteduster · Oct 4, 2024

BrowningRage · Oct 5, 2024

Lots of good guesses already. 196 2/8"

Dub · Monday at 2:29 PM

I hate it when a buck is really short changed, so sorry, if I'm way off on this one, but I'm getting 185"

Shadow · Monday at 9:24 PM

Cool buck. I’ll go 192.

Mallardsx2 · Tuesday at 4:38 AM

Shadow · 2024-10-12T08:51:45-0600

Is it Tuesday yet?

DeerAddiction4 · 2024-10-12T09:28:25-0600

Sorry forgot about this thread

Vitalwave · 2024-10-12T09:28:51-0600

DeerAddiction4 · 2024-10-12T09:30:01-0600

This might surprise most of you but he was 218 with a 209 frame.

Shadow · 2024-10-12T12:57:03-0600

Wow, I’d have been pleasantly surprised walking up on that one.

DeerAddiction4 · 2024-10-12T13:18:11-0600

Yea it was a surprise for sure.

johnnycake · 2024-10-12T21:03:52-0600

DeerAddiction4 said:
This might surprise most of you but he was 218 with a 209 frame.

I'm gonna be blunt. I'd have to see pics with the tape measure taking the measurements to believe that score. Unless you are adding the outside spread to the score too, then it would be believable.

Butts · 2024-10-12T23:06:12-0600

My experience is trail cam puts a buck 10” lower on frame and 20” on a bull, however isn’t this the same guy talking about a buck getting an inside spread credit of 26” if the longest main beam is 23”.. just fact checking.?

DeerAddiction4 · 2024-10-13T06:10:01-0600

johnnycake said:
I'm gonna be blunt. I'd have to see pics with the tape measure taking the measurements to believe that score. Unless you are adding the outside spread to the score too, then it would be believable.

He had an 29 inch inside spread. I will post score sheet. He also had some of the largest beams ever

Buckfever34 · 2024-10-13T08:07:23-0600

You have any pics of it “head on” ?

DeerAddiction4 · 2024-10-13T09:29:33-0600

I’ll have to go back and find some kill pics too.

DeerAddiction4 · 2024-10-13T10:47:53-0600

Here’s a bad picture of him that gives you an idea of his frame

johnnycake · 2024-10-13T11:05:23-0600

He's a great buck, no doubt.

But he's not a 218" gross buck using B&C measuring system. You can post a score sheet, sure, but without pics of the tape taking the measurements I'm not buying it.

DeerAddiction4 · 2024-10-13T12:54:40-0600

johnnycake said:
He's a great buck, no doubt.

But he's not a 218" gross buck using B&C measuring system. You can post a score sheet, sure, but without pics of the tape taking the measurements I'm not buying it.

He’s not 218 B&C he’s 218 gross

Butts · 2024-10-13T13:20:25-0600

DeerAddiction4 said:
He had an 29 inch inside spread. I will post score sheet. He also had some of the largest beams ever

What the hell am I not seeing? No way this buck has an inside spread of 29”. Largest main beams? So what’s the MB lengths?

johnnycake · 2024-10-13T14:28:14-0600

DeerAddiction4 said:
He’s not 218 B&C he’s 218 gross

Reread what I wrote: he's not a 218" gross buck using B&C measuring system.

The B&C measuring system produces a gross score and a net score.

The only way that buck scores 218" gross is if you don't follow the B&C measuring system. Like, for example, if you are adding both the absolute inside spread (as you have made clear in other threads that is what you do for "gross") AND you also add the outside spread (which is noted by B&C but not included anywhere in either the gross or net scoring), then I could see how you got about 30" of extra "score" over B&C gross by using the DeerAddiction4 system.