DeerAddiction4
Active Member
- Messages
- 356
We killed this buck in 2022. What do think he scores? I’ll post the score on Tuesday.
Guess The Score #3
- Thread starter DeerAddiction4
- Start date
DeerAddiction4
Active Member
- Messages
- 356
I’ll have to find some more pictures later.
Gunnihunter
Active Member
- Messages
- 943
fullthrottle
Very Active Member
- Messages
- 1,382
197
Buckfever34
Active Member
- Messages
- 448
202
yoteduster
Very Active Member
- Messages
- 2,312
198
BrowningRage
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 4,601
Lots of good guesses already. 196 2/8"
Mallardsx2
Active Member
- Messages
- 771
186
DeerAddiction4
Active Member
- Messages
- 356
Sorry forgot about this thread
DeerAddiction4
Active Member
- Messages
- 356
This might surprise most of you but he was 218 with a 209 frame.
DeerAddiction4
Active Member
- Messages
- 356
Yea it was a surprise for sure.
johnnycake
Active Member
- Messages
- 710
I'm gonna be blunt. I'd have to see pics with the tape measure taking the measurements to believe that score. Unless you are adding the outside spread to the score too, then it would be believable.
DeerAddiction4
Active Member
- Messages
- 356
He had an 29 inch inside spread. I will post score sheet. He also had some of the largest beams ever
Buckfever34
Active Member
- Messages
- 448
You have any pics of it “head on” ?
DeerAddiction4
Active Member
- Messages
- 356
I’ll have to go back and find some kill pics too.
DeerAddiction4
Active Member
- Messages
- 356
Here’s a bad picture of him that gives you an idea of his frame
johnnycake
Active Member
- Messages
- 710
He's a great buck, no doubt.
But he's not a 218" gross buck using B&C measuring system. You can post a score sheet, sure, but without pics of the tape taking the measurements I'm not buying it.
But he's not a 218" gross buck using B&C measuring system. You can post a score sheet, sure, but without pics of the tape taking the measurements I'm not buying it.
DeerAddiction4
Active Member
- Messages
- 356
He’s not 218 B&C he’s 218 gross
Butts
Very Active Member
- Messages
- 1,030
What the hell am I not seeing? No way this buck has an inside spread of 29”. Largest main beams? So what’s the MB lengths?
johnnycake
Active Member
- Messages
- 710
Reread what I wrote: he's not a 218" gross buck using B&C measuring system.
The B&C measuring system produces a gross score and a net score.
The only way that buck scores 218" gross is if you don't follow the B&C measuring system. Like, for example, if you are adding both the absolute inside spread (as you have made clear in other threads that is what you do for "gross") AND you also add the outside spread (which is noted by B&C but not included anywhere in either the gross or net scoring), then I could see how you got about 30" of extra "score" over B&C gross by using the DeerAddiction4 system.
DeerAddiction4
Active Member
- Messages
- 356
Will this satisfy you two? In all seriousness he was actually 217 and 7/8.
Edit- he only had a 28 inch inside spread. My fault.
Edit- he only had a 28 inch inside spread. My fault.
BrowningRage
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 4,601
He's an exceptional buck DeerAddiction... thanks for sharing.!
If I had killed him, I'd have been driving home saying, "Oh my gosh, I may have killed a 200" buck..." over and over. Then the tape would have made me a little light headed.
If I had killed him, I'd have been driving home saying, "Oh my gosh, I may have killed a 200" buck..." over and over. Then the tape would have made me a little light headed.
