I think it's odd so many NRs worry about management in Wyoming when their home states are in shambles. If Wyoming is doing it all wrong, why bother to apply? Feel free to not hunt here.
This is simply a forum for comments. If you read my post you will note that I said that I have no problem cutting NR tags, especially when mother nature cuts into the herd. When did I complain about Wyoming's management? I was simply commenting about someone wanting to eliminate all NR tags and expecting that to be the end all solution for improving quality/quantity for residents when they don't regulate their own numbers. I have mentioned previously that eventually even the ressy demand will exceed the resource. Also, my home state is NOT in shambles as you seem to know.
As to Montana, that's their decision to allow past residents different privileges. Don't like it? Well, feel free to not hunt there either.
You are a NR of Montana and brag that you shoot so many of "their" animals yet you come on here and complain that NR's are shooting all of the WY deer and ruining your quality/quantity. Wyoming allows NR hunters - if you don't like it, then don't hunt in Wyoming. Remember we are ALL a resident in only 1 state but we area all a NR in 49 other states.
At some point you're going to realize it's up to residents to decide how they manage their wildlife, not tourists.
Management is up to the WG&F and commission - not the residents. This is simply a forum for people to comment on. Believe it or not, everyone has an opinion and it doesn't have to align with yours or mine. I doubt that you and your opinions represent ALL of Wyoming. There are probably some residents out there that enjoy having relatives that have moved away come home and hunt, there are probably some outfitters that enjoy NR clients, there are probably some business owners that like on "tourist" income to help sustain their business.
Who said anything about quantity and quality remaining unchanged?
My comment was in response to "
Slash NR tags to zero to improve hunt quality for residents." Apparently, it is the NR's fault for "ruining" the quality even though several years ago there were a LOT more NR tags in G & H and over the years despite major tag cuts for NR's there is still a problem.
Please show me where hunting anywhere in Wyo, let alone G and H, is unrestricted?
My comment was only related to the subject at hand of unrestricted resident "general" tags in G & H. The NR tags can continue to be cut even to the point of eliminating them. But eventually some day unlimited resident demand will exceed the supply - maybe not now, or 5 years, or 10 years but eventually.
What causes the declines in population from one year to the next? Winter severity and weather conditions. Period! Full STOP!
Totally agree and never once disagreed or said otherwise. Other things do come into play such as the quantity/quality of winter habitat and available food.
Maybe where we differ in our opinions is that during those bad times when tag cuts are necessary, it is my opinion that simply cutting a few NR tags is meaningless in the overall management when the majority of the tags go unregulated. If the residents are complaining that the quantity and quality is not where it should be, then simply cutting a select few NR tags isn't going to really make any difference. As I stated NR tag cuts have been happening for years and continue to happen, but apparently that isn't achieving the desired results. At some point after all the NR tags are gone there will continue to be problems.
I can give you dozens of reasons why residents want general tags. I couldn't care less why a NR thinks we shouldn't, none of your business. Stay in your lane.
If residents want general tags that is fine with me and up to the WG&F and commission. But you also can't continue to have unregulated tags and expect the quality/quantity to remain. It is a fact that herds are diminishing all across the west while demand is increasing (even resident demand). Again, this is simply a forum for people to express their opinions. I'm not telling WY how to manage their deer - just making comments.
I missed where he’s complaining about NRs ruining the hunting in his state. Can you please quote?
In post #151 "
Slash NR tags to zero to improve hunt quality for residents."
I just wish at least one person could articulate what deer management issue would be solved by making these areas LQ for residents. Just one person. List out all the hurdles the growth of this herd faces and show me which one gets solved by LQ for residents.
So I read many posts that are stating to even further limit or even eliminate NR tags yet they go on to say nothing is gained from limiting tag quotas. So if limiting tags is the solution on one hand, then why have unregulated tag quotas on the other?
Won't happen, they are too caught in their sexual identity and fantasizing about @BuzzH kill photos.
At 59 years of age I have no S.I. issues - LOL.
And I have no envy of the same repeated kill pictures.