Mostly good thoughts and suggestions here. I've been outfitting in SE Wyo for 30 years now and have watched the elk in area 7 for longer than that. It is still a good area by Wyoming standards. The public lands get pounded so if you hunt there, please be in shape and know where you want to go, which will be in tough country as far as you can get from other hunters.
We only took 2 hunters in 7 in 2016. One got a 350 and the other had multiple chances at 350 bulls. He ended up with a respectable 6X6 but I didn't score him; maybe 310.
But area 7 peaked about 15-20 years ago. With 1500 bull licenses and people that often wait 5-10 years (residents and nonresidents) most people are real serious about hunting hard an getting a good bull. The quality is not what it once was due to all that pressure.
Our 2017 rifle hunts in area 7 are full. We (and other outfitters) take hunters in other areas. I hunt three other areas that I feel are increasing in quality. In fact, I apply in another area now because I think it's got better quality. Shooting 3,000-4,000 elk in one area over a 5 month season as is done in area 7 is hard on the critters.
I shot a cow on Dec 31 and there were at least 3 cows killed out of that group that day. I saw at least 6 hunters chasing that bunch and whacking elk. And on three different landowner situations.
I respect your dilemma. I'll be glad to try to help even if you don't want to hunt with us. I've done that for years and will continue to do it. I don't know much about the Cody area, but am pretty familiar with all of SE Wyoming and much of NE WY.
Best of luck to you guys and hope you get the bulls you have wanted and waited for.