Yup, your Innie is an Outie right now, elkantlers.
With that, I'll go as far as I'm ever going to right here, with some pessimistic assumptions based on a generalized request.
I'm going with NR, one point, non-special, that does not have the point option included, on public.
For third choice, any area around Gillette. Tags abound and there's a little decent land to hunt in each that is not just spread out state sections. A hunter can get a buck, but no other promises.
Second choice, going with the easy draw but decent lopes on more public land opportunity, I like 7 and 29. If 27 didn't have such long NR odds, I'd include it, but IMHO it is also nothing more than a "good" area at best.
For first, with fair odds, 75, 73, maybe 74. Some "good" opportunities we've had and fun hunting grounds, esp. campin' out.
Now if you were to take the point option, or just go for lucky on a first choice, that would change things, and my favorite picks, then down the line of choices, need an Inbox.
They're just a wee bit different from the conventional "wisdom" out there.