Which buck would you choose?

[WyomingTrophyHunter]

I don't know which buck I would choose. The white deer is a 24in 6x4 that is close to 18 tall, but the brown one is 24in wide with a cheater coming off the right antler, with a 7x5 frame. I don't know, depends on which one gave me the shot first. Which one would score higher?

SHuler

 

[MontanaTines]

I agree, whichever stepped out first!

 

[BuckSnort]

Both are nice bucks for sure. I would rather shoot the lighter colored one if I had a choice,I believe he would also score higher.

 

[fatrooster]

I like the brown one but either one would do in a pinch. fatrooster.

 

[HaremMaster]

HMMMM... WTH those look familar. I like the cheater buck!!! He's got some good mass, and character.. That's something you just don't see much of in that area. About a week till break...then we'll pick up some sheds!
Tanner