Both make a fine bow. But don't count out other manufactures. You need to shoot a bunch of bows and decide for yourself what feels the best. Some will be faster, or quiter, or smoother on the draw. You'll have to decide what is more important to you. But if I was putting down some cash right now on a new bow it would be on a bowtech tribute or a mathews xt.
Lots of reviews of bows over on archerytalk.