LAST EDITED ON Sep-15-14 AT 11:28AM (MST)[p]Great question, don't have any hard answers, just a couple observations from over the years
This is the mandible from a buck I killed this season, pretty worn down. The buck was always by himself in his little "crater" home range, and didn't like any other goats at all. Other bucks, does, it didn't seem to matter. Anyone that wandered into the crater got run off immediately, followed by a scrape with urine. He seemed to be a cranky old bugger even before I seen his teeth, but I have no idea how old he was, or how his horn size would correlate to his age...
We started seeing a crooked-horned buck up on our ranch back in 2009, and he is similar in that he is always alone, except during the rut proper, when he always has a large group of does he is tending. Have seen him every year since (last time just a couple weeks ago), and his horn size has remained pretty constant over the years, with maybe only a couple-three inches in variation. Though I do think this year is perhaps the smallest his horns have been, and he looks skinnier in the body as well. Again, I have no idea how old he is, but he's got to be getting up there. I'll see if I can dig up some pics of him from different years.
Maybe I should send in a tooth from this years bucker, as I'm now even more curious!
Anyway, very interesting topic, would love to learn more
Cheers,
Adam