Both are good sights, I myself have the same toxonics sight but just not in the tooless. I have a friend that was sponsored by copper john, he had one of their sight fail him in the middle of a 3d competition. He was winning and because the sight broke he lost first place and came in the middle of the pack. Though they were trying to make it right (they admited there was a flaw with his target sight and the newer ones didn't have that problem),he is now sponsored by Trophy Taker. Anyway besides that I have never heard of anything but good from copper john sight. Either way I think you can't go wrong.