My nephew is coming into town next weekend to go turkey hunting with me so I was just in the F&G office yesterday and I brought this up. The youth hunter has to be within hearing distance of an adult hunter with a license and same tag. This brought up another discussion in that those youth hunters wouldn't be able to apply for the youth controlled hunts if that were the case because (obviously) the adult hunter accompanying him/her would not be able to apply for those youth only controlled hunts as well. The woman at the front desk went to the back and got an answer from somebody. Take it for what it's worth, but as far as controlled hunts go, the answer I got was, if you are the one accompanying the youth hunter on his controlled hunt tag, you just have to have a tag (even a general season tag) for that same species in that same unit.
My example was, I hunt the unit 39 general elk hunt that is in November. I want my nephew to apply for a cow tag in unit 39 but I don't want to draw a cow tag myself. The woman confirmed that as long as I had a unit 39 general season elk tag (even though the dates are in November), I could be the one accompanying my (youth) nephew on a unit 39 cow elk tag if he were drawn for it (in October). You just have to have the same sepcies tag in the same unit, even if the dates don't everlap. For some reason I walked out of there wondering if I got the exact correct answer...
The alternative to this is, last year there was a youth controlled hunt in unit 44-2 (all of units 44,45 and 52). Obviously only youth hunters can apply therefore you can not put in as a group, but there are no open general seasons in any of these areas for the mentor so the youth hunter would not be able to use the Jr. Mentor program to their benefit? It just didn't add up.