It doesn't really matter what we think, its what Founder thinks. This is his site, dedicated to hunting and the outdoors and really it is our privelege to partcipate. The Forum rules have been the same since the beginning - they have not changed. All he is asking is that we follow those rules.
I can't speak for him but I have enjoyed that this site has always been free of charge, free of spam, free of verification checks that cost $$ (and would be the thing that he would ultimately have to use to keep an adults only page) and family friendly. This has always been a place on the internet (with the exception of a few posts here and there) that I feel totally comfortable viewing with my wife and children present. I would prefer it stay that way.
If you have an adult friendly portion of the website there is no way you can keep it from becoming totally XXX. Are you trying to tell me that you could trust the MM'ers to keep it PG13??? Give me a break. It would become a porn site and that means MM would be associated with porn. If that were to become the case, it would alienate a lot of hunters who use this site for solid information, advice and wholesome sociality. There is enough innuendo and innapropriateness as it is on the site without making it XXX. There are plenty of other sites out there where you can find what you are looking for if that is what you want.
UTROY
Proverbs 21:19 (why I hunt!)