Guess The Score #1

[DeerAddiction4]

I’m going to do a 5 week series of guess the score. Whoever gets the closest by the end of each week gets a congratulations from me lol. The rules are you get two guesses and at the end of the week I will post the score sheet and we’ll see who was the closest.

What do you think this guy scores? He’s a tricky one.

 

[Tristate]

181

 

[deerelkalope]

162 5/8

 

[link]

175

 

[lostinOregon]

163

 

[mlycrzy]

182

 

[BrowningRage]

183"
But the field photos make him look bigger!

 

[Dangbig]

178

 

[smokepolejohnson]

Juan 72 5/64” . Great looking Buck. Thx for the pics

 

[buckhorn]

169

 

[twopointdn]

172 6/8”

 

[SanJuan]

I don't think his beams are long enough to get a full spread credit so I'm saying 177.

 

[TeamRedDog]

171

 

[Shadow]

168

 

[JP]

183 3/8”

 

[mdbrown]

180 2/8

 

[NVarchery]

He's a wide bugger...178

 

[DeerAddiction4]

I don't think his beams are long enough to get a full spread credit so I'm saying 177.

No nets. Gross only

 

[mevertsen]

184 4/8

 

[Longun]

188

 

[buckhorn]

No nets. Gross only

Interesting!

I use the longer main beam for spread credit when Gross scoring.

I didn't realize some may use the full inside spread for gross score.
Is that common?

 

[DeerAddiction4]

Interesting!

I use the longer main beam for spread credit when Gross scoring.

I didn't realize some may use the full inside spread for gross score.
Is that common?

I’ve never met anybody who does it that way. I do it the spread from inside of main beam to inside of main beam at widest point.

 

[buckhorn]

I’ve never met anybody who does it that way. I do it the spread from inside of main beam to inside of main beam at widest point.

I'm sorry I didn't explain myself correctly.
What I'm saying is my understanding of spread credit is can only be credited up to the length of the longer main beam. Even for gross scoring purposes if you are allowing a wide buck full spread credit even if it's longer than the main beam I'm good with that I like it. I may have to remeasure a few of my bucks that will probably gross higher that way.

 

[BUGLEnmIN]

I'm sorry I didn't explain myself correctly.
What I'm saying is my understanding of spread credit is can only be credited up to the length of the longer main beam. Even for gross scoring purposes if you are allowing a wide buck full spread credit even if it's longer than the main beam I'm good with that I like it. I may have to remeasure a few of my bucks that will probably gross higher that way.

Yes that’s how it should be done.

 

[hunt30]

181

 

[yoteduster]

179

 

[buckhorn]

Yes that’s how it should be done.

Are you saying use the full inside spread for gross even if it's more than the longest main beam or no?
Thanks

 

[DeerAddiction4]

Yea

Are you saying use the full inside spread for gross even if it's more than the longest main beam or no?
Thanks

 

[buckhorn]

Yea

Cool I like it.

 

[Shadow]

If you’re going with full spread credit for gross, I’m going to raise my bid another 5 as well. 173.

 

[Dr_Hunter]

181,

 

[pauns08]

182 6/8"

 

[BUGLEnmIN]

Are you saying use the full inside spread for gross even if it's more than the longest main beam or no?
Thanks

Yes

 

[buckhorn]

Yes

OK then I will revise my guess up to 174 gross

 

[mta5672]

192

 

[CC11]

178 5/8"

 

[DBLung]

183 2/8"

 

[downhill]

186” doing it your way with full spread credit.

 

[DeerAddiction4]

Should I give you guys a G2 measurement for you to go off of for your second guess?

 

[Noel Arnold]

181 2/8

 

[Hunter21]

177 7/8

 

[greysriver]

170

 

[pushin_30]

179

 

[lostinOregon]

So we are using a different measuring system than BC and PY now on our guess?

 

[Joe2Kool]

Real guess, 187-3/8.
MM guess, 227-1/8.

 

[DeerAddiction4]

So we are using a different measuring system than BC and PY now on our guess?

Just gross

 

[lostinOregon]

BC and PY the inside spread cant be greater than the longest main beam. So if you’re asking for BC or PY gross that would include the deduction if the spread is wider than the longest main beam.

 

[DeerAddiction4]

They get a full spread credit. From inside of main beam to inside of main beam. No deductions

 

[huntin50]

170 gross

 

[Houndsman77]

173

 

[nontypical]

181 4/8

 

[lostinOregon]

They get a full spread credit. From inside of main beam to inside of main beam. No deductions

In true MM fashion. Why don’t we add 8 mass measurements per horn and outside inside of inside spread if we are just looking for a big number

 

[Rimrock]

172 3/8

 

[BrowningRage]

Guys, the spread credit has nothing to do with Net or Gross. The spread credit can only ever be either be the greatest inside spread of the main beams OR the measurement of the longer of the two main beams; whichever is smaller.

Given that B&C is a "scientific" documentation of symmetry, spread is actually a dumb measurement for them to have. But all hunters like to know how wide bucks are and they couldn't get past their inner hunter

 

[DeerHunter53]

I’m going to do a 5 week series of guess the score. Whoever gets the closest by the end of each week gets a congratulations from me lol. The rules are you get two guesses and at the end of the week I will post the score sheet and we’ll see who was the closest.

What do you think this guy scores? He’s a tricky one.

View attachment 157936

View attachment 157937

View attachment 157938

View attachment 157939

View attachment 157940

View attachment 157948

172

 

[lostinOregon]

Guys, the spread credit has nothing to do with Net or Gross. The spread credit can only ever be either be the greatest inside spread of the main beams OR the measurement of the longer of the two main beams; whichever is smaller.

Given that B&C is a "scientific" documentation of symmetry, spread is actually a dumb measurement for them to have. But all hunters like to know how wide bucks are and they couldn't get past their inner hunter

Yes it does. Under BC and PY the gross score is adjusted when the inside spread credit exceeds the length of the longest main beam.