GIANT idaho unit 45 deer

[IDAHOdale]

My lifelong buddy has finally gotten a golden ticket. The unit is nowhere what it used to be and this will be a difficult hunt but has the potential for a true desert king! We’re going to be scouting as much as possible between work and college courses. Wish us luck! I’m going to try and attach some photos of deer we’ve taken in southern idaho over the years just for your viewing pleasure

 

[twdjr]

Nice deer taken.

 

[Buckbrush]

Nice Bucks!

 

[Homer]

where's the buck from the title??

 

[SS!]

Great bucks! Good luck this fall!

 

[BrianID]

If all those bucks at OTC Idaho deer, you two have the skill to do much better in 45 than most. I hope you have a great time together and are rewarded for your efforts.

 

[BradA]

Good luck and be sure to let us know how the hunt goes. Congratulations on all the nice bucks you have taken.

 

[IDAHOdale]

where's the buck from the title??

We will hopefully have pictures by the end of October if we are lucky enough to find a big one

 

[IDAHOdale]

If all those bucks at OTC Idaho deer, you two have the skill to do much better in 45 than most. I hope you have a great time together and are rewarded for your efforts.

One was a draw archery the others were unlimited archery we’ve been fortunate to be able to spend so much time scouting and hunting this year will be tougher we can’t be out every day like prior years, but we’ll do our best! Thanks for the support

 

[SS!]

Well dale it’s like I always say, you put paint in a bucket and let it dry!

 

[IDAHOdale]

Well dale it’s like I always say, you put paint in a bucket and let it dry!

What exactly do you mean, it gets harder with age meaning hunting is getting more difficult each year?

 

[grizzly]

We will hopefully have pictures by the end of October if we are lucky enough to find a big one

Congrats on all the great bucks and good luck this year! Post tons of pics so we can see them.

 

[SS!]

What exactly do you mean, it gets harder with age meaning hunting is getting more difficult each year?

What I mean is you don’t put a dime in your shirt pocket if you have a dollar bill in your wallet

 

[IDAHOdale]

What I mean is you don’t put a dime in your shirt pocket if you have a dollar bill in your wallet

Ah yes thanks for the clarification, I too shake a cat when my dog runs away

 

[IDAHOdale]

What I mean is you don’t put a dime in your shirt pocket if you have a dollar bill in your wallet

If you mean we should stick to the hunts we are doing well maybe you are correct, but this gives us our best chance of breaking a legit 200 on a deer

 

[125nontypicalforky]

You know what they say “white water in the morning”

 

[IDAHOdale]

these old meaningless sayings are killing me hahahah or am I just too young to know….

 

[SS!]

Just remember anyone can put a cookie in a box, but it takes a real man to steam broccoli.

 

[Snoopdogg]

Sounds like Biden--nonsensical.

 

[rmanwill]

Congrats on some fine bucks. You should do awesome in 45. Can't wait to see the success.

 

[hawkbill]

Good luck

 

[BPKHunter]

Given it's such a low draw hunt, maybe you can feel comfy sharing some stories. Not all of us old guys will try and scare you off with saying that don't make sense to you. We would love to see some pics and hear how it goes, along your journey. Very excited for you!!

 

[IDAHOdale]

Well it’s been tough… lot of looking at heatwaves and not much else. We’ve gotten some permission on the top and hoping some of the better deer hide up there. Here’s the best we came up with, really looking to find something better that has more WOW factor

 

[HAP]

Some nice bucks, thanks for sharing.

 

[canyoncrosser]

I’d shoot him, but you can’t piss in a coffee filter and expect tasters choice.

 

[mod700]

Moonless night and a fast horse, it will look fine..........
Good luck on your hunt.
Mike

 

[IDAHOdale]

Moonless night and a fast horse, it will look fine..........
Good luck on your hunt.
Mike

Speaking of a moonless night, heavy little 4 that was using dark as his cover while he laid in some alfalfa. Sadly still haven’t found any target bucks should we worry? Who knows but we’re having fun regardless

 

[SS!]

The race is the end, the finish line is round

 

[usafvet]

I wouldn't get too worried yet. You still have a good amount of time before the hunt starts. I should be up scouting again here soon for my elk hunt there in 45 and will let you know if I see anything worth checking out.

 

[brdhuntr]

The last 3-days are the best in my experience.

 

[JPickett]

I spend a lot of time in 45 late in the year coyote hunting. I wouldn’t have my heart set on a 200” deer

 

[wetmule]

Good L???.................. you know.... the thing!

 

[Mallards_Only]

What Pickett said^^^. There might be 1 or 2 somewhere in the unit but I wouldn't consider 45 a "trophy" unit, especially during the archery hunt.

 

[JPickett]

I think he has the rifle tag. And no doubt you guys look like you know how to find mule deer so I’m sure you’ll find a nice buck. I just don’t know that You will find anything bigger then what you posted from your archery kills there. I’d be happy with any one of those caliber bucks out of 45

 

[GSJ]

I don’t get out there near as often as I used to but 45 mule deer is more legend than reality these days. The legend was real 30+ years back but that was a long time ago. Of course that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t give it your best shot good on you for scouting hard.

 

[IDAHOdale]

Yeah rifle tag and I agree with you guys. It’s well known to everyone that idaho doesn’t have a real trophy deer unit anymore, whether 45 was ruined by “that man” or not the potential is still there

 

[GSJ]

Yeah rifle tag and I agree with you guys. It’s well known to everyone that idaho doesn’t have a real trophy deer unit anymore, whether 45 was ruined by “that man” or not the potential is still there

Lol “that man”…you hear that Lowland?
Regardless of that I think the growth of the elk population has quite a bit to do with it. Also it’s known the tribe takes its toll on big bucks in the dead of winter or so I’m told.

 

[IDAHOdale]

Not looking to argue but “that man” brought the tribes and showed them the area. The elk population has been on a steep decline last three years if you ask me

 

[GSJ]

Not looking to argue but “that man” brought the tribes and showed them the area. The elk population has been on a steep decline last three years if you ask me

I don’t know sh*t about any of that but I’d think there has still got to be one or two giants out there. Hope you find them looks like you’re the man for the job.

 

[JPblind]

A lot of big 3x3s and 3x4s taking over the the unit with their genetics now. Good luck finding a solid frame 4.

 

[IDAHOdale]

Update, monster found

 

[Snoopdogg]

Pic or it didn't happen.

 

[GSJ]

Share photos AFTER you kill him.

 

[rmanwill]

Enjoy your hunt. Sounds like you already have had a blast scouting. Post up the adventure and good luck in getting him down. Waiting to see your success and photo of your scouting, hunting and the trophy.

 

[125nontypicalforky]

Whew! turns out “that man” didn’t have all the big bucks decimated! Hope you get him, you’re putting in the time

 

[Snoopdogg]

But where's the picture??? I want before AND after shots! HA!

 

[eelgrass]

Best of luck getting the big one. Remember, a wet bird never flies at night.

 

[BPKHunter]

Agree, keep pics of monsters until after the season or kill.

 

[Blindnonresident]

Gotta spook em off the private property first.

 

[IDAHOdale]

yes I have a video of him but am saving, have patience my friends

 

[Gator]

Good Luck hope he is a awesome buck.

 

[Snoopdogg]

yes I have a video of him but am saving, have patience my friends

As Afghanistan Joe would say, " Aww, c'mon man!"

 

[publichunter1]

Great bucks. I hope y'all find what you are looking for this fall!

 

[IDAHOdale]

Gotta spook em off the private property first.

Luckily we don’t being we can hunt a lot of the best properties

 

[Blindnonresident]

So if your hunting on the private you don't spook them off private?

 

[hawkbill]

Well if you can hunt the best properties there should be no excuses

 

[IDAHOdale]

Well if you can hunt the best properties there should be no excuses

Doesn’t mean it’s a gimme

 

[Blindnonresident]

This thread is useless.

 

[270Whatelse]

A buck in the hand is worth 2 in the bush.

 

[Blindnonresident]

Not if you believe in having deer for the future.

 

[JPblind]

Any luck at all? Or is this a dead thread?

 

[Ridge86]

Curious myself to??

 

[SS!]

Not curious at all but let’s hear it!

 

[JPblind]

Not curious at all but let’s hear it!

You're a dick!! I love it!!

 

[Ranger1]

Great bucks!

 

[IDAHOdale]

Any luck at all? Or is this a dead thread?

Tough finding big ones, still holding out

 

[IDAHOdale]

Best we’ve seen in season, does anyone want to share where a real big one is? Lol

 

[hawkbill]

Keep looking, last week looks good with the wheather

 

[usafvet]

Best we’ve seen in season, does anyone want to share where a real big one is? Lol

View attachment 56408

I haven't seen anything much bigger than that. I'm still trying to find some elk in an accessible area. If I see something I'll let you know

 

[JPblind]

I've seen no big bucks to speak of. Saw a few large 3x3s on the sage flats and some small 4x4s on top. Seen some bigger elk on top but a long way to walk from public. The elk this time last year were all down in the draws bedded but hopefully the weather will push some down. This was almost 2 weeks ago.

 

[Idahoron]

This hunt has been dieing a slow death. The huge number of elk hunts and elk plus over hunting have put a real hurt on this tag. It's no longer a golden ticket.

 

[usafvet]

The general season cow tags sure have not helped the elk population at all.

 

[steelheader]

This hunt has been dieing a slow death. The huge number of elk hunts and elk plus over hunting have put a real hurt on this tag. It's no longer a golden ticket.

you hit it on the head Ron, we have eatin the last 2 tags. the last one was by far the worst very few even 165 deer. very sad

 

[GSJ]

Idaho mule deer is and has been in a sorry state for quite a spell. Very sad for those of us who’ve watched it’s decline.

 

[DownThePipe]

45 has quality animals on private land. If you have connections with Larry Williams of Tree Top Ranches then you are in business. There a few other landowners also. Otherwise, just like many Idaho units, if you hunt the public you get the scraps. That’s how it goes.

 

[destroyer350]

Idaho mule deer is and has been in a sorry state for quite a spell. Very sad for those of us who’ve watched it’s decline.

why are you being so negative it's all good!

 

[JPickett]

45 has quality animals on private land. If you have connections with Larry Williams of Tree Top Ranches then you are in business. There a few other landowners also. Otherwise, just like many Idaho units, if you hunt the public you get the scraps. That’s how it goes.

Good luck with tree top. I know that guys cousin really well and he won’t let anyone on. He has some access yes around Fairfield but that’s the only stuff I know you can get on. Wrong unit too

 

[BrianID]

Best we’ve seen in season, does anyone want to share where a real big one is? Lol

Keep at it! Even if you don’t find a giant buck at least you will know you put in 100%.

The psychological aspect of hunting is an easy area to fail. For me it isn’t difficult to put in time scouting and hunt hard the first day or two of the season. It gets much more difficult when I’ve been hunting a few days and feel like I’ve seen everything there was to see. Many wise mule deer hunters have said that hunting for big bucks isn’t always fun.

After finishing some difficult hunts in Idaho I’m heading to Colorado and need a psychological boast myself. Even though my desire to hunt isn’t as high right now I’m just reminding myself to enjoy the experience. If I get lucky and locate a giant buck it will at least light that fire for a few days.

Keep grinding it out and you will at least have a chance of finding a buck you will be happy with. Your pictures provide proof that you have done it before and you can do it again!

 

[brdhuntr]

There is a ton of deer in 45 in the last week, they have been moving out of 43,and to some extent in 44. My buddy has the 45 bull tag, last weekend where he hadn't seen any deer, there literally 100's, and all on public!

 

[IDAHOdale]

Well we got it done. Never could find our target buck in season. Saw our best scoring buck in season on Thursday and let him walk. Regretted it that night went back the next morning and he presented a shot. The unit is not what it should be but was still a fun hunt hope you guys have enjoyed the updates. If anyone else had success in the unit do share it is always fun to see!

 

[BradA]

Dang nice buck! Congratulations how wide ? Glad to see you guys got it done.

 

[rmanwill]

Congrays and thanks for sharing. Pretty buck!!!

 

[IDAHOdale]

Dang nice buck! Congratulations how wide ? Glad to see you guys got it done.

Never put a tape to him surprisingly. I would guess he’s about 23 wide yet I believe he’s pushing 190 gross. What do you think?

 

[BrianID]

Never put a tape to him surprisingly. I would guess he’s about 23 wide yet I believe he’s pushing 190 gross. What do you think?

I think you are close.
congratulations!

 

[HGHCOUNTRY]

Pretty buck! Thanks for sharing all season!

 

[hawkbill]

Nice Buck Dale, I know a lot of good hunters out on the desert units, no one is seeing anything mature over 4 years old. If your asking us to guess score I would say around 178

 

[JPblind]

Congrats on a great heavy buck!!

 

[BradA]

In the ballpark.

Never put a tape to him surprisingly. I would guess he’s about 23 wide yet I believe he’s pushing 190 gross. What do you think?

 

[Mbogo]

Never put a tape to him surprisingly. I would guess he’s about 23 wide yet I believe he’s pushing 190 gross. What do you think?

Who cares. You and your buddy got to spend a lot of time together in a good unit and ended up successful. Sounds like you had a great fall already. Congrats.

 

[GSJ]

Nice buck. Not close to 190.

 

[Bigwiffy]

The horse that farts will never tire, the man that farts is the one to hire....171 2/8

 

[usafvet]

Congrats on the buck. You guys definitely put in a lot of time and work into your hunt.

 

[IDAHOdale]

Nice buck. Not close to 190.

You have inspired me to pick it up from the taxi and score it

 

[steelheader]

nice Buck, way to stick to it and go after a mature buck. dang rights its not what it used to be.
F&G have over hunted the hell out of it for several years. all the tags then the super tags.
then nobody wants to eat tag soup so they shoot some young dink. " Thats why we cant have nice things"

 

[BPKHunter]

Good job guys. Love the season long feedback. Respect your efforts.

Score wise, w inside spread ~20” and no eye guards, 190” would be tough, but nice forks and amazing symmetry

PS. F&G isn’t to blame, Mother Nature is.

 

[IDAHOdale]

I did my best without knowing how to officially score and not trying to give any extra length. 175 2/8
I have a 182 official scored buck that is very close in size so this makes sense

 

[JPickett]

mid 170's sounds a lot closer. nice buck

 

[publichunter1]

Congrats on a great buck!

 

[Bigwiffy]

Score doesn't mean anything. Great buck and nice write up. Remember in the land of the blind the man with one eye is king!

 

[DownThePipe]

this would be the age class of a buck born in the snowmageddon range.