I don't hunt from an ATV or a pickup, as I don't enjoy it and it just doesn't seem quite right to me. I really enjoy hunting that has some physical challenge to it, and this usually means hunting quite a ways from roads (this is often where the best hunting is too). Anybody that has packed out a few elk, especially in warmer weather or with grizzlies, understands the challenges of harvesting an elk far from the closest road.
I do not hesitate to use the best legal means to retrieve an animal, especially when considering the issues mentioned in the above paragraph. I have used horses (hired packers) a few times in the past when I needed to get the meat out quickly, and I have also spent days packing out elk by myself on my back when the weather permitted.
The reason I was looking in to ATV retrieval as a possible option is because I will be hunting in heavy grizzly country this year, and I am looking for the fastest legal option to get my meat out. I know of some people that have retrieved their elk with ATVs in Wyoming, but that may have been on BLM land? Thus, the reason for my post.
Even if I called in a packer, they would not be able to get there until the next day, and that might be too late. Also, the trees in the area I will be hunting are quite small and thus hanging the meat outside the reach of a grizzly will likely be difficult. If ATVs were an option, which it turns our they are not, it might be possible to get to the downed elk or close to it due to the type of terrain we will be in. I was thinking this might be the best possible option. Anyway, I guess I will need to find another solution.
As mentioned above, I am not a big ATV guy, but I definitely won't hesitate to use them if it is legal and it is necessary to ensure my elk does not go to waste.