littlebighorn
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 5,409
So trophy wise, what unit(s) in Wyoming holds the best antelope?
Best Wyoming Antelope Unit
- Thread starter littlebighorn
- Start date
ColoradoOak
Very Active Member
- Messages
- 1,920
Unit #1. No, really....
I have no idea. Good old Garth Carter has his 10 best, and I know 2 guys that drawed the 2 best units for big bucks on Garths list last year, and they said it was way overrated. One guy took his son to a unit that had tags left over, and the kid killed a bigger buck on that unit, than his dad did on Garth top 2. Plus he told me he seen 3 bigger bucks on his kids hunt, that was bigger than anything he seen on he top Garth pick.
PleaseDear
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 10,613
'lbh'-----I hope this will give someplace to start?
Following are the results based on the options you selected:
CATEGORY Pronghorn, YEARS 2005 to 2010, AWARDS MINIMUM 80, ALL-TIME MINIMUM 82, LOCATION Wyoming USA
SCORE LOCATION HUNTER OWNER DATE RANK
1. 91 2/8 Natrona, WY Michael J. Wheeler Michael J. Wheeler 2008 14
2. 89 6/8 Natrona, WY John Hinricks John Hinricks 2006 47
3. 89 4/8 Carbon, WY Donald E. Perrien Donald E. Perrien 2005 61
4. 88 6/8 Natrona, WY Mickey A. Anderson, Jr. Mickey A. Anderson, Jr. 2006 98
5. 88 4/8 Fremont, WY Patricia S. Brooks Patricia S. Brooks 2007 114
6. 88 2/8 Carbon, WY Bobby D. Raines Bobby D. Raines 2005 131
7. 87 6/8 Carbon, WY Jason H. Weber Jason H. Weber 2006 169
8. 87 6/8 Fremont, WY Patricia S. Brooks Patricia S. Brooks 2008 169
9. 87 2/8 Carbon, WY John G. Carnes John G. Carnes 2006 202
10. 87 2/8 Fremont, WY Flint B. Smith Flint B. Smith 2007 202
11. 87 Carbon, WY Brandon J. Hushbeck Brandon J. Hushbeck 2006 236
12. 87 Sweetwater, WY Jerry D. Dye Jerry D. Dye 2005 236
13. 87 Carbon, WY Dylan R. Snodgrass Dylan R. Snodgrass 2005 236
14. 86 6/8 Fremont, WY Kelly H. Dolph Kelly H. Dolph 2005 272
15. 86 4/8 Carbon, WY Travis R. Risner Travis R. Risner 2005 314
16. 86 4/8 Sweetwater, WY Levi J. Pope Levi J. Pope 2007 314
17. 86 2/8 Sweetwater, WY Shawn M. Plemel Shawn M. Plemel 2008 349
18. 86 2/8 Sweetwater, WY Jack E. Risner Jack E. Risner 2006 349
19. 86 2/8 Carbon, WY Suzanne Kawaters Suzanne Kawaters 2006 349
20. 86 Natrona, WY Eric W. McDonald Eric W. McDonald 2006 398
21. 86 Carbon, WY Ronald J. Hale Ronald J. Hale 2007 398
22. 86 Natrona, WY Hunter L. Scott Hunter L. Scott 2007 398
23. 86 Sweetwater, WY Charles K. Williams Charles K. Williams 2007 398
24. 86 Carbon, WY Terry A. Mason Terry A. Mason 2006 398
25. 86 Fremont, WY Phillip S. Craft Phillip S. Craft 2005 398
26. 85 6/8 Carbon, WY Greg A. Salisbury Greg A. Salisbury 2006 454
27. 85 6/8 Carbon, WY Larry S. Hicks Larry S. Hicks 2007 454
28. 85 6/8 Carbon, WY Miguel Martinez Miguel Martinez 2006 454
29. 85 4/8 Natrona, WY Peter J. Burke Peter J. Burke 2005 507
30. 85 4/8 Fremont, WY Karl K. Kukuchka Karl K. Kukuchka 2005 507
31. 85 2/8 Crook, WY Cleveland B. Holloway Cleveland B. Holloway 2005 564
32. 85 2/8 Carbon, WY William R. Chandler William R. Chandler 2005 564
33. 85 2/8 Natrona, WY Mike R. Bailey Mike R. Bailey 2006 564
34. 85 2/8 Natrona, WY Constantine C. Prodromakis Constantine C. Prodromakis 2006 564
35. 85 2/8 Carbon, WY Neil Q. Carrico Neil Q. Carrico 2006 564
36. 85 2/8 Carbon, WY Pat P. Jaure Pat P. Jaure 2007 564
37. 85 2/8 Sweetwater, WY Len H. Guldman Len H. Guldman 2007 564
38. 85 2/8 Natrona, WY Roger C. Krasnicki Roger C. Krasnicki 2007 564
39. 85 Sheridan, WY Garry Reese Garry Reese 2005 631
40. 84 6/8 Carbon, WY Scott M. Hushbeck Scott M. Hushbeck 2005 698
41. 84 6/8 Carbon, WY Matt D. Schuele Matt D. Schuele 2007 698
42. 84 4/8 Carbon, WY Timothy W. Stanosheck Timothy W. Stanosheck 2005 797
43. 84 4/8 Campbell, WY Gerald L. Frey, Jr. Gerald L. Frey, Jr. 2005 797
44. 84 4/8 Carbon, WY Jason L. Snell Jason L. Snell 2005 797
45. 84 2/8 Carbon, WY Brad A. Bartlett Brad A. Bartlett 2007 879
46. 84 2/8 Fremont, WY Mike Trevor Mike Trevor 2007 879
47. 84 2/8 Carbon, WY Buckie F. Hulme Buckie F. Hulme 2007 879
48. 84 2/8 Park, WY Thomas G. Obuhanych Thomas G. Obuhanych 2009 879
49. 84 2/8 Carbon, WY Eric D. Stanosheck Eric D. Stanosheck 2009 879
50. 84 Carbon, WY Mike R. Bailey Mike R. Bailey 2009 994
Getting the unit correct per County listing may be a challenge but alot of these countys only have 1-2 huge units in them.
Robb
Following are the results based on the options you selected:
CATEGORY Pronghorn, YEARS 2005 to 2010, AWARDS MINIMUM 80, ALL-TIME MINIMUM 82, LOCATION Wyoming USA
SCORE LOCATION HUNTER OWNER DATE RANK
1. 91 2/8 Natrona, WY Michael J. Wheeler Michael J. Wheeler 2008 14
2. 89 6/8 Natrona, WY John Hinricks John Hinricks 2006 47
3. 89 4/8 Carbon, WY Donald E. Perrien Donald E. Perrien 2005 61
4. 88 6/8 Natrona, WY Mickey A. Anderson, Jr. Mickey A. Anderson, Jr. 2006 98
5. 88 4/8 Fremont, WY Patricia S. Brooks Patricia S. Brooks 2007 114
6. 88 2/8 Carbon, WY Bobby D. Raines Bobby D. Raines 2005 131
7. 87 6/8 Carbon, WY Jason H. Weber Jason H. Weber 2006 169
8. 87 6/8 Fremont, WY Patricia S. Brooks Patricia S. Brooks 2008 169
9. 87 2/8 Carbon, WY John G. Carnes John G. Carnes 2006 202
10. 87 2/8 Fremont, WY Flint B. Smith Flint B. Smith 2007 202
11. 87 Carbon, WY Brandon J. Hushbeck Brandon J. Hushbeck 2006 236
12. 87 Sweetwater, WY Jerry D. Dye Jerry D. Dye 2005 236
13. 87 Carbon, WY Dylan R. Snodgrass Dylan R. Snodgrass 2005 236
14. 86 6/8 Fremont, WY Kelly H. Dolph Kelly H. Dolph 2005 272
15. 86 4/8 Carbon, WY Travis R. Risner Travis R. Risner 2005 314
16. 86 4/8 Sweetwater, WY Levi J. Pope Levi J. Pope 2007 314
17. 86 2/8 Sweetwater, WY Shawn M. Plemel Shawn M. Plemel 2008 349
18. 86 2/8 Sweetwater, WY Jack E. Risner Jack E. Risner 2006 349
19. 86 2/8 Carbon, WY Suzanne Kawaters Suzanne Kawaters 2006 349
20. 86 Natrona, WY Eric W. McDonald Eric W. McDonald 2006 398
21. 86 Carbon, WY Ronald J. Hale Ronald J. Hale 2007 398
22. 86 Natrona, WY Hunter L. Scott Hunter L. Scott 2007 398
23. 86 Sweetwater, WY Charles K. Williams Charles K. Williams 2007 398
24. 86 Carbon, WY Terry A. Mason Terry A. Mason 2006 398
25. 86 Fremont, WY Phillip S. Craft Phillip S. Craft 2005 398
26. 85 6/8 Carbon, WY Greg A. Salisbury Greg A. Salisbury 2006 454
27. 85 6/8 Carbon, WY Larry S. Hicks Larry S. Hicks 2007 454
28. 85 6/8 Carbon, WY Miguel Martinez Miguel Martinez 2006 454
29. 85 4/8 Natrona, WY Peter J. Burke Peter J. Burke 2005 507
30. 85 4/8 Fremont, WY Karl K. Kukuchka Karl K. Kukuchka 2005 507
31. 85 2/8 Crook, WY Cleveland B. Holloway Cleveland B. Holloway 2005 564
32. 85 2/8 Carbon, WY William R. Chandler William R. Chandler 2005 564
33. 85 2/8 Natrona, WY Mike R. Bailey Mike R. Bailey 2006 564
34. 85 2/8 Natrona, WY Constantine C. Prodromakis Constantine C. Prodromakis 2006 564
35. 85 2/8 Carbon, WY Neil Q. Carrico Neil Q. Carrico 2006 564
36. 85 2/8 Carbon, WY Pat P. Jaure Pat P. Jaure 2007 564
37. 85 2/8 Sweetwater, WY Len H. Guldman Len H. Guldman 2007 564
38. 85 2/8 Natrona, WY Roger C. Krasnicki Roger C. Krasnicki 2007 564
39. 85 Sheridan, WY Garry Reese Garry Reese 2005 631
40. 84 6/8 Carbon, WY Scott M. Hushbeck Scott M. Hushbeck 2005 698
41. 84 6/8 Carbon, WY Matt D. Schuele Matt D. Schuele 2007 698
42. 84 4/8 Carbon, WY Timothy W. Stanosheck Timothy W. Stanosheck 2005 797
43. 84 4/8 Campbell, WY Gerald L. Frey, Jr. Gerald L. Frey, Jr. 2005 797
44. 84 4/8 Carbon, WY Jason L. Snell Jason L. Snell 2005 797
45. 84 2/8 Carbon, WY Brad A. Bartlett Brad A. Bartlett 2007 879
46. 84 2/8 Fremont, WY Mike Trevor Mike Trevor 2007 879
47. 84 2/8 Carbon, WY Buckie F. Hulme Buckie F. Hulme 2007 879
48. 84 2/8 Park, WY Thomas G. Obuhanych Thomas G. Obuhanych 2009 879
49. 84 2/8 Carbon, WY Eric D. Stanosheck Eric D. Stanosheck 2009 879
50. 84 Carbon, WY Mike R. Bailey Mike R. Bailey 2009 994
Getting the unit correct per County listing may be a challenge but alot of these countys only have 1-2 huge units in them.
Robb
littlebighorn
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 5,409
Sweet Info Robb,
That list is mostly a handful of counties.
Thanks
That list is mostly a handful of counties.
Thanks
Good information and thanks for taking the time to do it. Considering the thousands taken each year, it also really put it into perspective how tough it is to get a B&C antelope.
----------------------------------------
Measure wealth by the things you have,, for which you would not take money.
----------------------------------------
Measure wealth by the things you have,, for which you would not take money.
PleaseDear
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 10,613
No problem Rick.....and the rest of ya.
It actually is 5 freaking pages of Wyo B&C Antelope but 90% of them are from the very same counties as the Top 50.
I have max pts on Antelope as a Non-Ressy....BFD....but....I am squaring away my first choice for March application--'cheapie fee' of course! ha
I do have a pretty good Lock on my 2nd choice.....
Rick ya want the full 5 pages----I'll toss 'em over to ya?
Robb
It actually is 5 freaking pages of Wyo B&C Antelope but 90% of them are from the very same counties as the Top 50.
I have max pts on Antelope as a Non-Ressy....BFD....but....I am squaring away my first choice for March application--'cheapie fee' of course! ha
I do have a pretty good Lock on my 2nd choice.....
Rick ya want the full 5 pages----I'll toss 'em over to ya?
Robb
P
pirogue
Guest
I'm building points for the Red Desert also. Before the preference point system started, I hunted in Niobraro county and when people look at the mount that came from there, I like to say that it came from the least populated county in the least populated state in the United States.
lostinOregon
Very Active Member
- Messages
- 2,187
I spoke with a bioligist in 07 before I hunted a "premier" unit in Carbon county just after he did his summer count before hunting season. He counted something like 8,000 antelope and he told me that he saw about 10 that he felt would go book. Even in the best units they are not behind every sagebrush patch. They are one in a thousand at best but I bet there is a booner in every Wyoming unit. You just have to find it.
Rich
Rich
littlebighorn
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 5,409
Robb,
I appreciate all your work, but I like your Cliff Notes version!
It would take me all night to analyze 5 pages of statistics, besides I am probably hoping to draw a second choice somewhere decent.
Rick
I appreciate all your work, but I like your Cliff Notes version!
It would take me all night to analyze 5 pages of statistics, besides I am probably hoping to draw a second choice somewhere decent.
Rick
PleaseDear
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 10,613
Ya got a mzzy loader?
Robb
Robb
I didn't know the red desert units were in Carbon county,I thought they were mostly in Sweetwater county. I agree, Carter is pulling a fast one, is his #1 unit still 60? Actually I think the red desert units are way over rated, maybe too many dry years have changed things. That buck recently killed in Natrona county, at 91 2/8 inches and not even 15 inches long, its quite amazing.
H
HuntElk4Fun
Guest
Robb... sweet list! When you compare the latest magazine with that list of counties and units, looks to me Carters have it dead on. 9 of their top 10 match up.
>>91 2/8 inches and not even 15 inches long
Goes to show you mass is it for speet goats!
>>91 2/8 inches and not even 15 inches long
Goes to show you mass is it for speet goats!
sageadvice
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 11,849
I want to put my .02 cents in favor of excellent hunting in units other than those most highly ranked.
I made time for 7 days of hunting lopes last year in a area that doesn't take any points to draw. The first 3 days of my hunt, my rifle stayed in the camper, wrapped up and in the gun case as it was when i left home. I looked at an unbelievable amount of antelope bucks, sometimes, most of the time, over a hundred bucks each day, almost all on public or accessible ground.
I never did see "Mr. BIG" but i finally picked from the many and ended up taking a nice 80" antelope! I was more than happy with that portion of my trip and would highly recommend anyone to plan plenty of time, look at all the bucks possible, and they too should have a wonderful trophy hunt. Thanks!!
Joey
I made time for 7 days of hunting lopes last year in a area that doesn't take any points to draw. The first 3 days of my hunt, my rifle stayed in the camper, wrapped up and in the gun case as it was when i left home. I looked at an unbelievable amount of antelope bucks, sometimes, most of the time, over a hundred bucks each day, almost all on public or accessible ground.
I never did see "Mr. BIG" but i finally picked from the many and ended up taking a nice 80" antelope! I was more than happy with that portion of my trip and would highly recommend anyone to plan plenty of time, look at all the bucks possible, and they too should have a wonderful trophy hunt. Thanks!!
Joey
Silentstalker
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 3,234
Well said Joey.
Take your time and look over the goats. Antelope are tough to judge and looking over a bunch is probably just as important as which unit your in. I have never hunted Wyoming but have been involved in several hunts here in Utah. Antelope are a blast to hunt!
Nice info Robb. Good luck on your draw too!
Take your time and look over the goats. Antelope are tough to judge and looking over a bunch is probably just as important as which unit your in. I have never hunted Wyoming but have been involved in several hunts here in Utah. Antelope are a blast to hunt!
Nice info Robb. Good luck on your draw too!
ridgerunner
Very Active Member
- Messages
- 1,966
what units are considered the "red desert". Is it primarily 57,58,59 or do 60 and 61 get included as well and potentially others.
