Boone and Crockett or not?

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

elkhunterUT · Oct 21, 2020

That is a buck you don’t stop to think about score-he is a shoot first and worry about score later type of buck.

Is he in play for you this year? Better get him killed.

Snoopdogg · Oct 21, 2020

Uh, hell yeah!

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

elkhunterUT said:
That is a buck you don’t stop to think about score-he is a shoot first and worry about score later type of buck.

Is he in play for you this year? Better get him killed.

Yes, hopefully... he lived on my land last year and i didnt have a tag. I drew one this year but havent seen him yet. Fingers crossed as the rut approaches.

Gunnihunter · Oct 21, 2020

No brainer. Shoot!

Ranger1 · Oct 21, 2020

Great buck!

ithunter · Oct 21, 2020

send it.

WHT_MTNMAN · Oct 21, 2020

Big ol body, giant head and face. Yep he will do

Stubaby · Oct 21, 2020

Judas!!!!!

jester · Oct 21, 2020

Definitely

Broadside_Shot · Oct 21, 2020

To answer your question... I think he would make Boone and Crocket

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

Broadside_Shot said:
To answer your question... I think he would make Boone and Crocket

Hopefully he made it thru winter!

mevertsen · Oct 21, 2020

Kill him and find out!

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

mevertsen said:
Kill him and find out!

Going to try!

Wapitiwilly · Oct 21, 2020

All day long????

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

Wapitiwilly said:
All day long????

Getting nervous now. Lol hope hes alive still....

Pines_N_Tines · Oct 21, 2020

Hands down he'll make the 180" net minimum for the awards book. Depending on symmetry he might make the 190" net minimum for the all time book. Regardless of score he would be a true trophy on the wall. A great looking buck.

huntin50 · Oct 21, 2020

I bet you he nets in the 190"S. He is a tank with good forks, big eye gaurds and good mass. Good luck.

Homer · Oct 21, 2020

I don’t think he’ll net book. Beams are not super long...inside spread is not super wide....and G3’s are not special.....and....he has a little trash to deal with..

Just my opinion of the original question

BrianID · Oct 21, 2020

Really nice buck and I have no doubt his gross typical frame is over 190". However, it is too hard for me to tell if he would net 190" based on the pictures. I wouldn't doubt he could net 190"+ but as Pine_N_Tines mentioned "Symmetry" is very important for a net score over 190"
I would say shoot first and score him after he is on the ground.

Tristate · Oct 21, 2020

Yes. He will make it. Good luck. Hope you get him.

legacy · Oct 21, 2020

Have you killed him yet?

legacy · Oct 21, 2020

How about now?

DH56 · Oct 21, 2020

You don't hesitate on this one-

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

huntin50 said:
I bet you he nets in the 190"S. He is a tank with good forks, big eye gaurds and good mass. Good luck.

Thanks

sjhgraysage · Oct 21, 2020

I hope you can turn him up!
?

hornkiller · Oct 21, 2020

Good luck and post a picture that is a giant in my book!

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

hornkiller said:
Good luck and post a picture that is a giant in my book!

For sure fingers crossed!

hunt30 · Oct 21, 2020

Absolute smoker buck for sure, and I’d shoot without hesitation, but from the quality of the photos, I’m not sure if he’s even a typical 4 point let alone a book head.

Longun · Oct 21, 2020

You ain't ever gonna know if he's still walkin' and breathin'

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

Longun said:
You ain't ever gonna know if he's still walkin' and breathin'

My tag is for Nov 18-22 we will see...

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

hunt30 said:
Absolute smoker buck for sure, and I’d shoot without hesitation, but from the quality of the photos, I’m not sure if he’s even a typical 4 point let alone a book head.

Hes non typical was an 8 x 9 last year lots of sticker points.

DidIDraw · Oct 21, 2020

Spectacular buck - best of luck to you

hunt30 · Oct 21, 2020

Green Giant said:
Hes non typical was an 8 x 9 last year lots of sticker points.

I can see what looks like a couple of extras on his right. I can’t tell if he has a g3 on his right though. Hope you get him. Buck of a lifetime

DesertRanch · Oct 21, 2020

Kill him. Worry about the score much later. First be thankful for a successful hunt. Then scream and dance a jig. Then just stare at him for a long while. Score is about 15th on the list. KILL HIM!!!

Homer · Oct 21, 2020

Green Giant said:
Hes non typical was an 8 x 9 last year lots of sticker points.

his only hope is as a typical...

elkassassin · Oct 21, 2020

So Homer?

You Gonna LOW-BALL The Buck?

That's an MM'er 260 Right There!

Homer said:
I don’t think he’ll net book. Beams are not super long...inside spread is not super wide....and G3’s are not special.....and....he has a little trash to deal with..

Just my opinion of the original question

Solotude · Oct 21, 2020

That’s a sweet buck!!! Score doesn’t matter with a deer like that. He’s seen a few winters.....

SS! · Oct 21, 2020

I’d say the chance that buck makes book is about the same chance of seeing that buck again. Zero.

Muleman1 · Oct 21, 2020

Absolutely

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

Solotude said:
That’s a sweet buck!!! Score doesn’t matter with a deer like that. He’s seen a few winters.....

For sure!

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

Slightlysober said:
I’d say the chance that buck makes book is about the same chance of seeing that buck again. Zero.

He loves on my property

Green Giant · Oct 21, 2020

Green Giant said:
He loves on my property

Lives

antlerradar · Oct 22, 2020

Green Giant said:
Lives

Sounds like loves there to. If he is still alive he will be back in a week or two.
As for B&C. Looks like he might trash out. Nothing bad about that.

cosmic_cowboy · Oct 22, 2020

Most of us will never even see a buck like that in our lifetime, who cares if he makes book. Measure him when he's on the ground.

Gator · Oct 25, 2020

Any luck turning up his sheds from last year.
Shoot 1st and often.

Homer · Oct 25, 2020

cosmic_cowboy said:
Most of us will never even see a buck like that in our lifetime, who cares if he makes book. Measure him when he's on the ground.

very few get measured on the hoof.....

grizzly · Oct 25, 2020

It's hard to tell from the pics, but if he's 8x9 I doubt he makes book. He's probably one of those bucks that would have a better chance at B&C as a Typical if he didn't have the trash than he'll score as a NT with the kickers.

This is where B&C falls short, IMO. That's a great buck. Forget the book and hunt him until you get it done. It will be fun to see what he looks like this year.

I hope he shows up. Good luck.

Green Giant · Oct 25, 2020

Gator said:
Any luck turning up his sheds from last year.
Shoot 1st and often.

No, but not from lack of looking. Ruts about to start we will see.

Str8shtr · Nov 23, 2020

Any luck turning him up?

Green Giant · Nov 24, 2020

Str8shtr said:
Any luck turning him up?

No unfortunately he didnt return this year.
I harvested the most mature animal on the property though.

Str8shtr · Nov 24, 2020

Nice buck! Congrats!

Green Giant · Nov 24, 2020

He was mature just not the one i was after.

link · Nov 24, 2020

Nice buck. Glad to see you made it off that damned island.

buckspotter7 · Nov 26, 2020

Nice buck, Congrats! Sorry that monster didn’t show. Let us know if you get a glimpse of him later

Boone and Crockett or not?

Member

Member

Long Time Member

Long Time Member

Member

Active Member

Very Active Member

Member

Active Member

Very Active Member

Active Member

Active Member

Member

Very Active Member

Member

Very Active Member

Member

Active Member

Very Active Member

Long Time Member

Very Active Member

Long Time Member

Very Active Member

Very Active Member

Active Member

Member

Very Active Member

Long Time Member

Member

Active Member

Long Time Member

Member

Member

Active Member

Active Member

Active Member

Long Time Member

Long Time Member

Active Member

Long Time Member

Very Active Member

Member

Member

Member

Active Member

Very Active Member

Long Time Member

Long Time Member

Long Time Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Active Member

Active Member

Similar threads